threemonkeys (
threemonkeys) wrote2006-03-22 10:57 am
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Entry tags:
Cold Turkey
I'm trying to kick a habit and this may be my best opportunity. The addiction in this case is the reading of Harry Turtledove alternate history series. Each book in one of these series is huge and the series can easily span half a dozen volumes or more. The books are entertaining in a mindless kind of way - the lives and loves of a bunch of characters who make their way through the changed reality that is a Turtledove universe. From time to time there is a chance to say "ooh he is referring to that bit of history", but mostly it is just about the characters' lives. Very much like a soap opera or reality show really.
The thing is, I have reached the point where the two series I was reading have both finally been wound up. I have not started on any of the numerous others and I intend to keep it that way. From now on the only Turtledove books I will read are the stand-alone stories. Not all of those either - my experience with the incredibly tedious Ruled Brittania leaves me wary.
The actual trigger for this resolution is that I have finished reading Out of the Darkness - book 6 in the Darkness series. This is the WW2 as a fantasy world series. It follows sixteen different characters. That is a huge number of POV characters which is why it is no wonder that the books fatten to the size they are - typically 650+ pages. There is no point in trying to describe it further - if you know Turtledove, then you know what to expect. If you don't then you wouldn't start with this one and I would suggest that you don't start on any of them at all unless you have vast acres of time at your disposal.
The thing is, I have reached the point where the two series I was reading have both finally been wound up. I have not started on any of the numerous others and I intend to keep it that way. From now on the only Turtledove books I will read are the stand-alone stories. Not all of those either - my experience with the incredibly tedious Ruled Brittania leaves me wary.
The actual trigger for this resolution is that I have finished reading Out of the Darkness - book 6 in the Darkness series. This is the WW2 as a fantasy world series. It follows sixteen different characters. That is a huge number of POV characters which is why it is no wonder that the books fatten to the size they are - typically 650+ pages. There is no point in trying to describe it further - if you know Turtledove, then you know what to expect. If you don't then you wouldn't start with this one and I would suggest that you don't start on any of them at all unless you have vast acres of time at your disposal.
no subject
I'm trying hard to think of a correlation between the accuracy of the history and ease of reading and I can't really come up with one. At least within the confines of alternate-reality novels. His non historical stuff is certainly easier to read than his historical stuff.
no subject
I can see why his hsitorical stuff slows down - he takes on the tones of some of his sources, including the cademic one. And he feels the need to flesh out background a lot more. He also explores causes and consequences in greater detail: there is a lot less assumed and a lot more explained. And just doesn't it make sense that these are the books *I* like, since I have spent large chunks of my life reading matters historical. I find the other books a bit Turtledove-lite.
My particular addictions are things with salt. Chips. Pickles. Deep fried with salt is best of all. (I have salad for lunch and can't see any way to make it anything other than healthy.)
no subject
no subject
no subject